US rare buffalo nickels for coin collectors and other buyers

Home › Coins › United States coins › US nickel and half-dime coins ›

US rare buffalo nickels for coin
collectors and other buyers

FIND US BUFFALO NICKELS FOR SALE

In 1913, the United States Liberty head “V” nickel was replaced with a new design: the buffalo nickel. This five-cent coin featured a large close-up of a Native American man in profile on the obverse, and a buffalo on its reverse giving the coin its popular name.

The coin’s design was somewhat controversial, as some felt that the Indian head was too large; additionally, the bison on the reverse gave the mints in Philadelphia, San Francisco, and Denver, who all minted the coin, problems with some of its smaller details. In 1937, a worker at the Denver mint accidentally removed one of the buffalo’s legs, resulting in perhaps the buffalo nickel’s most famous variation.

Greece coins: Unique collectibles from southern Europe

Several great collectible examples of the buffalo nickel are for sale in the marketplace. Check the current vendors’ items for sale and come back to see daily updates. The buffalo nickel lasted from 1913 until 1938, when it was replaced by the Jefferson nickel. 

US buffalo nickels for sale

Currently showing our favorite 206 offers from eBay. Click for shipping details and money-back guarantee info. US buffalo nickels listings are chosen using MegaMinistore's original custom technology. We show you only the latest and best offers from safe, trusted sellers. Offers are updated and refreshed every day.

When you click a link to a merchant and make a purchase, it can result in this website earning a commission. Affiliations include, but are not limited to, eBay Partner Network. 

Showing 1 - 10 of 206

ONE SHOTGUN ROLL 40 BUFFALO NICKEL FIVE CENT PIECES OLD COIN LOT! 1913-1938

Seller: oldcoppercoins ★★★★★★★★★★ 99.5% (4,643 ratings)
Location: United States

5% OFF
$59.00
$56.05 or best offer

Limited-time deal. Buy It Now Price

(ITM-8862) 1916-P Buffalo Nickel ~ AU+ Condition ~ COMBINED SHIPPING!

Seller: ngm-18 ★★★★★★★★★★ 99.9% (8,887 ratings)
Location: United States

$79.95 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

(ITM-8875) 1923-P Buffalo Nickel ~ AU+ Condition ~ COMBINED SHIPPING!

Seller: ngm-18 ★★★★★★★★★★ 99.9% (8,887 ratings)
Location: United States

$89.95 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1914 Early Year Buffalo Nickel receive coin pictured #6832

Seller: more_than_common_cents ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (6,126 ratings)
Location: United States

$69.99

Buy It Now Price

Buffalo Nickels Circulated Lot of 41

Seller: dopamine74 ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (102 ratings)
Location: United States

$77.99 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

(ITM-8887) 1927-D Buffalo Nickel ~ Very Fine (VF) Condition ~ COMBINED SHIPPING!

Seller: ngm-18 ★★★★★★★★★★ 99.9% (8,887 ratings)
Location: United States

$79.95 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1938 D Buffalo Nickel NGC MS65 Toned

Seller: dollarstorecardman ★★★★★★★★★★ 99.9% (2,182 ratings)
Location: United States

$55.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

1919 Philadelphia Mint Buffalo Nickel Uncirculated

Seller: em135052 ★★★★★★★★★★ 100% (364 ratings)
Location: United States

$99.99

Buy It Now Price

1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C Key Date San Francisco Mint Fine/VF Details RARE DATE

Seller: adkcoin ★★★★★★★★★★ 93.8% (14 ratings)
Location: United States

$90.00 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

(ITM-8891) 1927-S Buffalo Nickel ~ Very Fine+ (VF+) Cndtn ~ COMBINED SHIPPING!

Seller: ngm-18 ★★★★★★★★★★ 99.9% (8,887 ratings)
Location: United States

$79.95 or best offer

Buy It Now Price

Show
1 - 10 of 206

Browse more on MegaMinistore