Was the “Country Is Red” 1968 Chinese error stamp without Taiwan really a design mistake?

Nov 3, 2009   More articles: Asian stamps (1); China stamps (1); East Asia stamps (1); Stamps (1); Taiwan stamps (1)

china-taiwan-error-stamp"The Whole Country Is Red", says the stamp in Chinese. Indeed, the background of the 1968 issue has a map of China all filled in red. Except, glaringly, the island of Taiwan, which is shown but merely outlined with a thin red line, rather than filled in solid red. (Surrounding countries are not shown at all.) So what is the point? Taiwan is not red... and thus not part of the country? Scandalous!

The designer, Wang Wei Shang, claimed it was a mistake, and for several years feared jail time for his transgression. Taiwan has long claimed independence from China, which considers Taiwan (formerly called "Formosa") part of its country. The issue is so touchy that Chinese authorities have been known to confiscate tourists' guide books if the books show Taiwan as a separate state.

The stamp was issued for a single day in 1968, then immediately withdrawn several hours later by authorities when it was discovered that the stamp appeared to separate China and Taiwan. Although keeping such a stamp as a curiosity was bold in and of itself, a few did survive and now are sold for very high prices. At a recent auction in Hong Kong, a total of seven stamps showing the mistake sold for HK$6,610,000, nearly US$853,000.

But was this really an error? One assumes that there were panels and officials who approved designs and checked the production of the stamp along the way; the contrast of a big red China and a blank Taiwan is so striking that it is not really possible to miss it. In fact, ones eye is drawn to it almost immediately.

Perhaps the officials involved thought the depiction of Taiwan was intentional, reasoning that the stamp's design reflected the controversial, or at least 'special', status of Taiwan. That would be incredibly out-of-character behavior from communist Chinese officials, however. Even if the designer wanted to make a barbed political point, foolish as that would seem, it would require several officials not noticing or being in collusion to actually see the stamp through to public sale. (Note that as soon as it went on sale, it was pulled; it's that obvious.)

This is all speculation on our part, but it seems unbelievable that this glaring 'error' made it so far with nobody realizing it. The Taiwan issue was so touchy that it seems that part of the stamp would have been scrutinized more than others; it's not as if a shirt on one of the workers at the bottom of the stamp was accidentally left uncolored. It looks for all the world like Taiwan was left uncolored on purpose; that it was not merely a matter of forgetting to fill in the shape but that a conscious decision was made to leave it blank.

How it got as far as it did before being caught is something we'll leave to conspiracy fans. One thing seems certain though: it is unlikely this was merely an innocent designer's lapse.

Comments about this post

1 comment

Feb 6, 11:33 pmfpdhgis [unregistered]

cCqEQI ynqepmtvhwjl, [url=http://mgouaxiginhp.com/]mgouaxiginhp[/url], [link=http://wznplxyxkhez.com/]wznplxyxkhez[/link], http://jfmioxafjigt.com/

Leave a comment

You are not signed in; please sign in or fill out this form to comment.

Screen name: Required

Email (not made public): Required

Website:

Human test: Add these numbers together: 6 + 12 Required

(check spelling — no editing possible!)

Asian stamps for sale

Hover over tab to show items; click tab to see page.

Available now on AmazonCurrently available Asian stamps sales from Amazon.com, including third-party sellers. See item page at Amazon for shipping details.
2005 Chinese New Year #3895 Two-Sided Pane Of 24 X 37 Cents Us Postage Stamps

2005 Chinese New Year #3895 Two-Sided Pane Of 24 X 37 Cents Us Postage Stamps

New: $5.99

Buy at Amazon »

Vintage India Stamp Lot #2

Vintage India Stamp Lot #2

Collectible: $1.00

Buy at Amazon »

Lot Of China (9) Stamps

Lot Of China (9) Stamps

Used: $1.01
Collectible: $1.99

Buy at Amazon »

"Elite Overseas Chinese" Commemorative Stamp Dr. Tei-Fu Chen

"Elite Overseas Chinese" Commemorative Stamp Dr. Tei-Fu Chen

Used: $100.00

Buy at Amazon »

Russia Russian Soviet Union Postage Stamps Block Of 4 State Visit Of Brezhnev To India Issued 30 Dec 1980 MNH

Russia Russian Soviet Union Postage Stamps Block Of 4 State Visit Of Brezhnev To India Issued 30 Dec 1980 MNH

New: $6.50

Buy at Amazon »

Asian stamps — see all 49 MMS listings from Amazon »

East Asia stamps for sale

Hover over tab to show items; click tab to see page.

Right now on eBayWe constantly scan eBay to find East Asia stamps listings from a variety of sellers and categories, including misspellings, abbreviations, and foreign-language listings.
Macau Stained Glass & Sacral Art..Stamp Set

Macau Stained Glass & Sacral Art..Stamp Set

Join bidding: $0.80

Buy at eBay »

N.Korea Stamps: North Korean Leader Meets World Leaders

N.Korea Stamps: North Korean Leader Meets World Leaders

Join bidding: $0.99

Buy at eBay »

China Taiwan 2160 - Postal Savings Ann. (Pf60854)

China Taiwan 2160 - Postal Savings Ann. (Pf60854)

Buy now: $1.00

Buy at eBay »

Prc China 1983 T87 Beijing Opera B-Sf Booklet Vf

Prc China 1983 T87 Beijing Opera B-Sf Booklet Vf

Join bidding: $6.96

Buy at eBay »

1957 Korea 5Th Anniv Of Joining Itu Fdc *Yd

1957 Korea 5Th Anniv Of Joining Itu Fdc *Yd

Join bidding: $3.99

Buy at eBay »

East Asia stamps — see all 10,000 MMS listings from eBay »

China stamps for sale

Hover over tab to show items; click tab to see page.

Right now on eBayWe constantly scan eBay to find China stamps listings from a variety of sellers and categories, including misspellings, abbreviations, and foreign-language listings.
Prc China 1983 T87 Beijing Opera B-Sf Booklet Vf

Prc China 1983 T87 Beijing Opera B-Sf Booklet Vf

Join bidding: $6.96

Buy at eBay »

Prc China 1983 T84 Tomb Of The Yellow Emperor Booklet

Prc China 1983 T84 Tomb Of The Yellow Emperor Booklet

Join bidding: $2.96

Buy at eBay »

Prc China 1982 T77 Fan Painting Of Ming&Qing Booklet

Prc China 1982 T77 Fan Painting Of Ming&Qing Booklet

Join bidding: $2.96

Buy at eBay »

China Pr 2483-6 Bl Blocks MNH Famous People

China Pr 2483-6 Bl Blocks MNH Famous People

Buy now: $3.20

Buy at eBay »

Prc China 1992-2003 Zodiac New Year Stamp Set MNH Vf

Prc China 1992-2003 Zodiac New Year Stamp Set MNH Vf

Join bidding: $12.96

Buy at eBay »

China stamps — see all 10,000 MMS listings from eBay »

Taiwan stamps for sale

Hover over tab to show items; click tab to see page.

Right now on eBayWe constantly scan eBay to find Taiwan stamps listings from a variety of sellers and categories, including misspellings, abbreviations, and foreign-language listings.
China Taiwan 2160 - Postal Savings Ann. (Pf60854)

China Taiwan 2160 - Postal Savings Ann. (Pf60854)

Buy now: $1.00

Buy at eBay »

China -Taiwan ... Early Stamps On Piece W/ Ovptd Geese

China -Taiwan ... Early Stamps On Piece W/ Ovptd Geese

Join bidding: $55.55

Buy at eBay »

Taiwan - Large Used Collection

Taiwan - Large Used Collection

Join bidding: $16.50

Buy at eBay »

China - Taiwan Nice Early Cover Zakow/Chekiang To Usa

China - Taiwan Nice Early Cover Zakow/Chekiang To Usa

Join bidding: $17.00

Buy at eBay »

R.O. China Taiwan 1992 Endangered Mammals F S/S Animal

R.O. China Taiwan 1992 Endangered Mammals F S/S Animal

Buy now: $7.00

Buy at eBay »

Taiwan stamps — see all 6,025 MMS listings from eBay »